Latest news and information

We regularly update this site with news from the world of human resources, whether it's changes to legislation or sharing of best practice:

 

Latest news:

 

Age Discrimination

Retirement Procedures

Statutory Dismissal and Grievance Procedures

Employers lack awareness of obligations for pregnant workers
Smoking and the Workplace
How are your interview skills?

Information and Consultation Draft Regulations

The Cost of Labour Turnover

Do you recruit temporary staff through Recruitment Agencies?

 


Archived news
 

 

 

Would you like to receive our newsletter on a regular basis?
We hope that you have found these news items useful. If you, would like to receive a copy on a regular basis please contact Perfect Clarity Ltd e-mail info@perfectclarity.co.uk

Disclaimer

 

Age Discrimination

The Employment Equality (Age) Regulations 2006 

The regulations make it unlawful to discriminate against workers, employees, job seekers and trainees on the basis of their age (this applies to people of all ages, both old and young).  The regulations cover recruitment, terms and conditions of employment, promotions, transfers, dismissals and training.  They do not cover the provision of goods and services.   

In common with other Equality legislation, the regulations make it unlawful to: 

  • Treat someone less favourably because of their age (Direct Discrimination). 
    • e.g. it would be unlawful to refuse to promote an individual just because they are over 50.

       
  • Apply a criterion, provision or practice which disadvantages people of a particular age (Indirect Discrimination)
    • e.g.  if applicants for a management position were unreasonably required to have 10 years of management experience, younger managers (who may be fully capable of meeting the requirements for the role) would be disadvantaged.
       
  • Harass someone on the basis of their age. 
    • e.g.  taunting someone because they are “long in the tooth” or “wet behind the ears”.

There are limited circumstances when it is lawful to treat people differently because of their age, such as, if the employer has an objective justification, which can be demonstrated with valid evidence.  For example, an employer may be able to set a maximum age for recruitment into a particular role, if this is to reflect the considerable training requirements of the position, and the need for a reasonable period of employment before retirement.   

Other Changes from 1st October 2006 

  • The upper age limits for unfair dismissal and redundancy rights will be removed.
  • A national default retirement age of 65 will be introduced, making compulsory retirement below 65 unlawful (unless objectively justified).
  • A legal right for employees to request to work beyond compulsory retirement age, which employers have a ‘duty to consider’.  Employers are also obliged to give employees at least six months notice of their retirement date.

What do the regulations mean in practice?

The regulations apply to all areas of employment, but are likely to have the biggest impact in the following: 

Recruitment

Employers need to review recruitment practices to ensure that judgements are based on objective evidence about a candidate’s ability to do the job, rather than assumptions about their age.  In particular you should check the following: 

  • Review your recruitment documentation (job / person specifications and adverts) to ensure that you are not imposing any unjustifiable requirements relating to age.  Specifically you should avoid defining experience in terms of years, as this may rule out younger people who have the skills but have not had the opportunity to demonstrate them over an extended period. 
  • Check the language that you use in your recruitment documents, particularly job adverts.  Avoid using language that might imply that you are looking for someone of a certain age (e.g. “mature”, “young” or “energetic”).
  • Age should not be used as a criterion to determine which applicants to shortlist for interview.  Ideally, you should remove details of a candidate’s age and date of birth from your application form. 
  • Avoid asking age related questions at interview (e.g. “This is a very young team, how would you feel about being the oldest?  “How do you feel about managing older people?”).
  • Make sure that everyone involved in the recruitment process is aware of these regulations (and other equality legislation).

Retirement

  • If you have a retirement age of less than 65, it will need to be objectively justified.  Otherwise increase your retirement age to 65, or remove it all together.
  • Employers have an obligation to notify employees in writing of their retirement date at least 6 months in advance (See article below on retirement procedures).
  • Employees can request to work beyond retirement age.  If the employee chooses to do so, you should set up a meeting to consider the request.  However, employers are not obliged to agree to requests to work beyond retirement age. (See article below on retirement procedures)

Pay and Benefits

  • Employers can continue to relate pay and benefits to length of service (e.g. pay rates, holiday entitlement, sick pay provision etc.) up to a maximum of five years service.
  • To retain any pay and benefit provision that requires more than five years service you need to:
    • Demonstrate that the service criterion reflects higher levels of experience, rewards loyalty or increase motivation.
    • Have reasonable grounds to conclude that using length of service in this way fulfils a business need.
    • The regulations do not alter the provisions of the National Minimum Wage.

Redundancy

  • The application of age related criteria in the selection for redundancy will be unlawful.  The use of criteria relating to length of service (including “Last in First Out”) is also likely to be indirectly discriminatory. 
  • The application of statutory redundancy payments will be lawful (despite the calculation continuing to be based on age related criteria).
  • Care should be taken in enhancing redundancy payments due to either an employee’s age or length of service.  However, it will not be unlawful to enhance statutory redundancy pay by removing the maximum amount of a week’s pay, or by multiplying individual’s statutory redundancy pay by a consistently applied figure.

What will be the impact of Age Discrimination Legislation?

We don’t know yet, however, we may gain some insight from the experience in the Republic of Ireland.  Age discrimination was outlawed in Ireland in 1998, and age related claims now make up 19% of Irish employment cases.

UK employers would be wide to take note of the following cases:

  • Ryanair advertised for a position stating that they wanted “a young and dynamic professional”.  This was found to be age discriminatory and the Company was fined 8,000 Irish Pounds.
  • An accountancy company advertised for staff with “2 to 3 years post qualification experience”.  An applicant with 20 years experience successfully claimed that he was discriminated against on the basis of his age, when his application was rejected because he was “too senior”.  The Company was ordered to pay 10,000 Euros in compensation.
  • A young female manager won her claim for age related harassment when referred to as a “young foolish girl” by an older male employee. 

Further Information 

www.dti.gov.uk/employment/discrimination/age-discrimination/index.html  

www.acas.org.uk

 

top

 

Retirement Procedures

In order for a retirement to be fair after 1st October 2006, employers will need to demonstrate that: 

  • The retirement will take effect at the default retirement age of 65 (or at the employer’s normal retirement age, if this is different).
  • The employee has been given written notice of their retirement date, and advised of their right to request to continue working.

Transitional Arrangements from 1st October 2006 until 31st March 2007

When a retirement is due to take place during the transitional period (1st October 2006 to 31st March 2007), employers must:

  • Notify the employee in writing of their retirement date, giving the longer of contractual or statutory notice.
  • Advise the employee in writing of their right to request to work beyond retirement age.

An employee who wishes to exercise this right during the transitional period, should make a written request as soon as reasonably possible once notified of their retirement (preferably at least 4 weeks before retirement).  Note that employees can make a request up to 4 weeks after employment has been terminated, during the transitional period. 

The Full Retirement Procedure from 1st April 2007

The full retirement procedure will apply for retirements after 1st April 2007: 

  • Employers must notify employees in writing of their retirement date between 6 and 12 months in advance.  The written notification should include details of the employee’s right to request to work past retirement.
  • Should the employee wish to exercise the right, they must make their request in writing at least three months before their retirement.
  • Once a request is received the employer should arrange a meeting with the employee to discuss the request.  The employee has a right to be accompanied to this meeting by a fellow worker or trade union representative.
  • The employer is not obliged to accommodate an employee’s request.  However, any request must be fully considered during the meeting with the employee.
  • The employer should communicate their decision in writing, offering the right to appeal.  Whilst employers do not have to provide reasons for turning down a request, it would be good practice to do so.
  • Where the employee decides to appeal, a further meeting must be arranged.  Again the employee has a right to be accompanied, and any decision must be communicated in writing.

What should employers do now?

  • If you have employees due to retire during the transitional period you should write to them as soon as possible, to provide notice of retirement (in line with the transitional arrangements above).

Put a procedure in place to ensure that employees are automatically notified of their retirement date (and right to request to work beyond retirement) between six and twelve months in advance.

 

top

 

Statutory Dismissal and Discipline Procedure

From 1st October 2004, when an employer contemplates dismissal the Statutory Disciplinary Procedure must be followed:

Step 1  The employer must advise the employee in writing of the allegations against them or the reasons that dismissal is being contemplated.

Step 2   The employer invites the employee to a disciplinary hearing to discuss the issues.  The employee has a right to be accompanied by a fellow employee or trade union representative.  The employer informs the employee of the outcome of the disciplinary hearing.

Step 3  The employer informs the employee that they have a right to appeal.  Where the employee takes up this option, the employer must set up an appeal hearing.  The employee has a right to be accompanied to the appeal hearing by a fellow employee or trade union representative.  The appeal decision is final and the employee is notified of the outcome.

The statutory dismissal and disciplinary procedure applies to dismissals in a wide range of circumstances including:

  • Misconduct
  • Capability (including ill health terminations)
  • Redundancy
  • Non renewal of fixed term contracts
  • Early retirement

A failure by an employer to follow the statutory procedure will make any dismissal automatically unfair.  Employment Tribunals will now be able to increase compensation by up to 50% in cases where an employer has failed to follow the statutory procedure.  They will also be able to decrease compensation by up to 50% in cases where the employee has failed to follow the statutory procedure (e.g. failing to attend the disciplinary hearing, failing to appeal). 

All employers will be required from 1st October 2004, to produce a written document setting out their disciplinary rules and procedures.  Employers also have to include a reference to disciplinary rules and procedures within the Written Statement of Employment Particulars (or employment contract).  Employment Tribunals will be able to award an employee up to four weeks pay as compensation, should their employer fail to issue a Written Statement of Employment Particulars (or if the document is inaccurate or incomplete).

Statutory Grievance Procedure

From the 1st October 2004, when an employee raises a grievance about their employment, employers will need to comply with the requirements of the Statutory Grievance Procedure:

Step 1  The employee must inform their employer of their grievance in writing.

Step 2  The employer must invite the employee to a meeting to discuss the grievance.  The employee has the right to be accompanied by a fellow employee or trade union representative.  The employer informs the employee of their decision following the meeting.

Step 3  The employee has the right to appeal against the employer’s decision.  In these circumstances the employer must invite the employee to attend an appeal hearing.  The employer informs the employee of their decision following the appeal hearing. 

The Statutory Grievance Procedure also applies where an employee raises a grievance after termination of employment.  In such circumstances a modified procedure may apply, allowing the employer to review the grievance without holding a meeting and to respond in writing. 

Employees will be unable to proceed to Employment Tribunal unless they have raised a written complaint with their employer and waited 28 days for a response.  Again if either party fails to follow the statutory procedure, Tribunals may increase or decrease any compensation by up to 50%.

What Should Employers Do?

  • Review existing Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures and make sure that they comply with the requirements of the legislation.  If you have separate procedures for handling complaints of bullying and harassment, ensure that these also incorporate the requirements of the Statutory Grievance Procedure.
  • If you do not have Disciplinary or Grievance Procedures, as a minimum you must introduce a written document outlining the statutory requirements. 
  • Review your Written Statement of Employment Particulars (or employment contracts) to ensure that reference to your Disciplinary Rules and Procedures and Grievance Procedure is included.
  • Ensure that all employees are aware of your Disciplinary and Grievance rules and procedures (e.g. include them in the Employee Handbook, display them on Notice Boards, incorporate them into Induction Training).
  • Make sure that you apply the Statutory Dismissal and Disciplinary Procedure for all dismissals. Do not forget that the procedure also applies to dismissals resulting from a non renewal of a fixed term contract, ill health terminations and redundancy.
  • Ensure that the Statutory Grievance procedure is applied to all grievances, even those arising after employment

This article has been designed to provide an overview, rather than a comprehensive review of the legislation.  Full details and guidance for employers can be found on the DTI website www.dti.gov.uk/er/resolvingdisputes.htm

Disciplinary and Grievance Toolkit

We have produced an employer toolkit which includes sample letters, forms and process flow charts to help managers with administrative requirements when handling disciplinary and grievance issues.  The toolkit costs £45 + VAT.  Follow the link for more information http://www.perfectclarity.co.uk/toolkits.htm

top

 

Employers lack awareness of obligations for pregnant workers

A 2004 survey by the trade union Usdaw indicated a lack of awareness amongst employers of the legal rights of pregnant workers.  The survey of Usdaw members found that:

  • 22% of respondents did not get paid time off for ante-natal appointments (this is a legal right).  More than 10% of the women were told to work the time back.

     
  • More than 70% of respondents said that either no risk assessment had been carried out or they didn’t know whether one had been undertaken.  It is a legal requirement for employers to conduct individual risk assessments for pregnant workers.

Confused about maternity?  Perfect Clarity has developed a Family Friendly Working toolkit for employers.  Priced at £45 + VAT the toolkit contains comprehensive guidance on maternity.  A risk assessment form for pregnant workers is included, along with sample letters and forms to support the administration of maternity, paternity, parental leave and flexible working requests.  Follow the link for more information. http://www.perfectclarity.co.uk/toolkits.htm

top

 

Smoking and the Workplace

 The UK Government is under pressure to follow Ireland’s lead in banning smoking in all workplaces.  ASH (Action in Smoking and Health) are campaigning for bars, restaurants and clubs to be made smoke free zones.  They argue that working in a smoke filled environment is a health and safety issue.  As a result, employers are urged to take steps to protect their staff from the health risks associated with passive smoking.  A clear smoking policy, communicated to all employees, is a sensible approach for employers concerned with minimising the risk of legal action. 

top

 

How are your interview skills?

In many parts of the country it is a job applicant’s market at the moment, with employers facing tough competition to recruit talented new staff.  A recent survey of 4000 jobseekers, carried out by recruitment consultancy Reed, found that an organisation’s approach to interviews can have a dramatic impact on their ability to recruit.  Two thirds of candidates reported turning down jobs because the organisation failed to impress them during the interview.  Whilst 85% of respondents stated that it was vital for the organisation to make a good first impression at interview.

The survey’s 4000 respondents quoted a surprising range of complaints about interviews, including:

  • Candidates being left hanging around for up to 3 hours without any explanation for the delays.

  • Scruffy interviewers.

  • Unprepared interviewers who had not read c.v.s in advance.

  • Inappropriate flirting.

  • Bad language.

  • Interviewers taking phone calls during the interview.

Don’t forget that the candidate is assessing your organisation, as much as you are assessing them during the interview.  Selection interviewing is an important skill with which few people are born.  All interviewers should be trained to enable them to effectively assess candidates, and to create a good first impression of the organisation.

For further information on recruitment and selection training visit www.perfectclarity.co.uk/training/recruitment_and_selection.htm, to discuss how we can support your recruitment campaigns email info@perfectclarity.co.uk

top

 

Information and Consultation Draft Regulations

The Government has issued draft regulations designed to encourage greater communication between employers and staff.  “The Information and Consultation of Employees Regulations” will come into effect in March 2005 (for employers with more than 150 employees).  This new legislation is in addition to current regulations requiring consultation in connection with TUPE or collective redundancies.

Under the regulations, where at least 10% of staff make a request an employer is obliged to implement an information and consultation mechanism (e.g. this may take the format of a Works Council).  Employers can negotiate for up to 6 months with employees about the information to be provided.  However, where no agreement is reached standard provision will apply, which state that the employer must provide information on:

  1. Recent and likely developments of the employer’s activities and economic situation e.g. the trading position.

  2. The situation, structure and likely development of employment e.g. details of new jobs or redundancies.

  3. Decisions likely to cause substantial change to the work organisation or contractual relationship e.g. changes to terms and conditions.

The standard provisions also require employers to consult over items b. and c. above.  Such consultation must be carried out with a view to reaching employee agreement.

The introduction of the regulations will be phased, affecting employers with 150 + employees in March 2005, those with 100 – 150 employees in March 2007 and those with 50+ employees in March 2008.  Employers with less than 50 employees are exempt.  Where employers do not comply with the regulations a fine of up to £75,000 may be imposed. 

top

 

The Cost of Labour Turnover

Did you know that on average it costs UK employers £9,766 to recruit and train a new employee?  A recent study by Momentum Financial Services also found that average labour turnover in UK companies is 17.9% per annum. 

There is no doubt that some turnover of staff is beneficial, as it allows the recruitment of people with new skills, ideas and different experiences.  However, if your organisation has a high level of labour turnover, the cost can clearly be enormous.  What can you do to reduce it?

  • Find out why people are leaving.   It may sound obvious, but unless you know why people are leaving you cannot hope to address the right issues.  Carry out exit interview or send a questionnaire to all leavers, to find out about their decision to leave.

  • Act on the information from your exit interviews / questionnaires.

  • Is pay an issue?  Employers often assume that pay is the primary reason why people leave organisations.  Interestingly, research seems to suggest that relationships with managers and the lack of career development opportunity are often more significant reasons.  However, if pay is an issue, consider carrying out a survey amongst local employers.  This will enable you to find out how your pay and benefits really compare in the employment marketplace.  You may find that the cost of addressing any pay gap can be off set against the current cost to your organisation of labour turnover.

Need any help?  We have plenty of experience of analysing and addressing labour turnover issues.  For a free review of your labour turnover issues, why not email us info@perfectclarity.co.uk

top

 

Do you recruit temporary staff through Recruitment Agencies?

Many employers have experienced being charged a “temp to perm” fee by a recruitment agency, when permanently employing a long term agency temp.  If this has caused you frustrations in the past, the “Conduct of Employment Agencies and Businesses Regulations” which come into force on 6th April 2004 may present some good news.

The regulations state that, after the end of a “relevant period” the client will now have the right not to be charged a “temp to perm” fee.  In brief, the “relevant period” will be the longer of either:

  • 8 weeks after the temp / contractor last worked for the client.

  • 14 weeks from the first day that the temp / contractor first worked for the client.

The regulations outline other provisions relating to the way in which employment agencies operate.  Further information can be found by visiting www.dti.org.uk.

top

 


Would you like to receive our newsletter on a regular basis?

We hope that you have found these news items useful. If you, would like to receive a copy on a regular basis please contact Perfect Clarity Ltd by e-mail info@perfectclarity.co.uk
 

 

Disclaimer


These news items are not intended to be a definitive analysis of employment legislation. In the event that you have a specific issue professional advice should be taken.

top